Compare
ParcelPanel vs Aftership
How does ParcelPanel compare with AfterShip? What’s the best platform to deliver a good post-purchase experience to shoppers? What is the best alternative to AfterShip? Discover why ParcelPanel is a great competitor to AfterShip.
Overview
ParcelPanel and AfterShip both enhance the post-purchase journey, but they cater to different merchant priorities.
ParcelPanel is purpose-built for Shopify, helping 50,000+ Shopify merchants streamline tracking, returns, and notifications, all while improving customer satisfaction and driving repeat purchases. With a generous free plan, a 7-day trial, and plug-and-play setup, ParcelPanel is a cost-effective and scalable choice for fast-growing DTC brands.
AfterShip provides an all-in-one post-purchase solution, including shipment tracking, returns management, customer notifications, etc.. Supporting 1,100+ carriers and integrating with major eCommerce platforms, it helps businesses reduce support tickets and boost delivery transparency. Ideal for mid-to-large merchants seeking advanced automation and multi-platform integration.
Built with Shopify merchants in mind
ParcelPanel isn’t just compatible with Shopify—it’s built for it. From dropshipping mode to syncing return statuses directly to your Shopify admin, every feature works seamlessly within your workflow. No messy integrations or workarounds, just a smooth experience tailored for your store.
Smarter returns that protect your profits
With ParcelPanel, returns aren’t just smoother—they’re smarter. You can offer refunds to store credit or gift cards, set incentives to drive exchanges, and support green or box-free returns. It’s a more thoughtful way to handle returns—built to keep customers happy and revenue in your pocket. AfterShip also offers return features, but many are locked behind enterprise plans.
Discover how ParcelPanel compares with Aftership
Here's a complete comparison between ParcelPanel and AfterShip. * Information as of June 19, 2025. Updates welcomed if any discrepancies are found.
ParcelPanel
Aftership
General
Built for Shopify
Standardized Order Statuses
9
8
Carrier Integrations
Carrier Integrations 1,400+
1,200+
Carrier Auto-Detection
Automatic Tracking Information Sync
CSV Import
CSV Export
Dropshipping Mode
Custom Order Status
Shipping Protection
Warranties
Returns & Exchanges Management
✔. Sync return status and operation records to the Shopify backend; one dashboard to manage all returns.
Returns Status Tracking
Merchant side
Merchant side
Headless Support
API & Webhook Access
Branded Tracking Page
Embedded Tracking Page
Order Lookup Widget
Customization
Supports CSS & HTML, with code examples available
Drag-and-drop page editor, supports custom CSS
Themes
2
2
Shipment and Pre-Shipment Tracking
Shipment tracking
Split Shipment Tracking
Items and Other Items in Orde
Show items in order
Show items in order, and other items with links to track them
Subscription Widget
Product Recommendation
AI-powered recommendation and specific collection setup
AI-powered product collection, and manual selection
Estimated Delivery Date
Flexible timeframe setting, advanced settings based on destinations, automatic correction with tracking info from carriers
Custom Shipment Status
Support 3 custom pre-fulfillment statuses
Custom pre-shipment statuses
Ready for Pickup Location
Last-Mile Delivery
Last-mile carriers: YunExpress, Yanwen, 4PX, AliExpress Standard Shipping, CNE Express, CJ Packet, and YDH
Return Request Widget
Shipping Protection Widget
Shipment Review Block
Instagram Feed
Text & Image & Video Widget
Tracking Page Languages
34
34
SEO Title & Description
Tracking Page URL Changes
Tracking Detail Replacement
Tracking Page Variations
Redirect from Shopify Order Status Page
Tracking Clips
Enterprise paln
Customer Segmentation
Enterprise plan
Photo Proof of Delivery
Enterprise plan
Gift Tracking
Enterprise plan
Automated Shipping Notifications
Notification Types
Email
Email, SMS, Webhook, and WhatsApp
Delivery Status Triggers
7
16
Pre-Built Email Templates
✔
Product Recommendation Widget
✔
✔
Discount Upsell
✔
✔
Branding Remove “Powered by XX.”
✔
✔
Email Template Languages
English + full translation in other published languages + optional auto-adaptation by customer language
Supports multilingual emails and SMS
Editor Type
Visual & HTML editor
Drag-and-drop & HTML email editor
Email Sender
Customizable
Customizable
Estimated Delivery Dates
Post-Purchase EDD
Pre-Purchase EDD
Shipping Protection
Type
Shipping Protection: Powered by Seel, customer-paid insurance
Package Protection: Powered by InsureShield; Customer-paid insurance
Carbon Neutral Shipping
Coverage of Protection
Loss, damage, delay, and theft
Loss, damage, and theft
Protection Widget
At the cart drawer/cart page and the checkout page for Shopify Plus stores
Shopping cart for Shopify stores and checkout page for Shopify Plus stores
Claims Resolution
24/7. Consumers can file a claim through emails sent by Seel and the branded tracking page.
24/7. Consumers can file a claim through email, the branded claim page, and the branded tracking page.
Order Refunds
Within 48 hours on average, sent via email on a prepaid credit card for quick resolution
2-5 business days. Reship with the same items or refund to the original payment/store credit. Automation is available.
Markets and Currencies
Supports 8 markets and 6 currencies: the United States, Germany, France, the Netherlands, the United Kingdom, Australia, Canada, and New Zealand; USD, CAD, GBP, EUR, AUD, and NZD.
Supports 1 market and 1 currency: the United States; USD.
Returns Management
Return Management Dashboard
Return Reasons by Product
Return Zones and Routing Rules
Branded Return Page
Embedded Returns Page
Customize Return Page URL
Order Matching Method
Order Number + Email or Phone Number, Email + Email verification
Order Number + Email, or Phone Number, or Shipping Postal Code
Return Request Widget
✔. You can add it to the order status page for one-click request returns.
Gift Return Widget
Enable customers to exchange items purchased as gifts
Allow customers to return a gift and choose either a refund to store credit, or a replacement.
Marketing Assets
Customization
Visual editor
Visual editor
Return Page Languages
Sync the store's published language
23
Return Policy Summary and Entrance
Return Policy
Custom Return Policy URL
Return Policy Customization
Automated Return Notifications
Notification Types
Email
Email
Email Sender Info
Editable
Editable
Return Status Triggers
7
11
Pre-Built Email Template
Customizable + supports liquid variables
Customizable + supports HTML template
Email Template Languages
English + full translation in other published languages + optional auto-adaptation by customer preference
Multilingual (Essential plan)
Return Solutions
Refund to the Original Payment Method
Exchange for the Same Items
Exchange for Different Items/Shop Now
Variant Exchanges
Instant Exchanges
Partial Bundle Exchanges
Pre-Discount Credit
Refund to Store Gift Card
Refund to Store Discount
Refund to Store Credit
Gift Returns
Free Returns
Free Return Widget
Shopify checkout or cart
Shopify checkout or cart
Custom Rules for Free Returns
Return Reasons
Return Reason Library
Add Return Reasons
Create Reason Groups
Return Shipping
Return Address
Ship with Return Labels Provided by Merchants
Door-to-Door Pickup
Ship on Your Own
Drop Off in Store
✔. Supported carriers: USPS - US.
Box-Free Drop-Off
Green Returns
Printerless Returns (QR code)
Return Logistics Carrier
17 more carriers and custom integration
53 more carriers
Return Shipping Labels
Set return label fees, support up to 3 return labels for each request
Packing Slip
Negotiated Rates
USPS discount code
Return Rules
Return Window
Flexible return window start date: order created, fulfilled, and delivered (Requires Tracking plan)
By fulfillment date, order date, delivery date (Requires Tracking plan)
Special Return Window
Return Routing
Basic Rules
Allow one or multiple intens to be returned
Limit one return request
Blocklist
Product SKU limit
Restocking Fee
Flexible setting rules
Shipping Fee
Return Rewards
Incentivize customers to choose specific return options, like “refund to store gift card.”
Return Fraud & Abuse
Wear and return
Empty Box Scam
Fraud Analysis
Anti-Fraud Workflows
Return Automation
Auto-Approve Returns Request
Flexible Auto-Refund Options
Auto-Mark as Received
Exchange Order Automation
Auto-Restock
Rich Automation Rule Builder
Analytics
Shipment & Tracking Analytics
Shipment, order-to-delivery time, transit time, exceptions, order lookup, and shipping notification reports
Shipment, order-to-delivery time, transit time, one-time shipment, exceptions, shipment events, notifications, tracking pages, page tracking clips, shipment reviews, Apple Wallet order tracking, benchmarks reports
Marketing Performance Insights
Tracking page and shipping notifications reports
Tracking page and shipping notifications reports
Returns and Exchange Analytics
Exchange upsell value, retained revenue, return requests data, return rates, return shipping costs, shipping fee, restocking fee, return rewards, return variants, return reasons
Return request, return rates, return values, saved revenue, top return reasons, top return by variant, refund rate, exchange rate, new revenue, return shipping methods, customer country/region, Avg. resolution time, automated returns
Saved Revenue (via shipping protection)
Third-Party Integrations
Order Tracking Integration
2 eCommerce platforms (Shopify, Shopify Plus & WooCommerce); 50+ popular tools, including PayPal, Shopify Flow, PageFly, GemPages, Klaviyo, Yotpo, Judge.me, Zendesk, Gorgias, Weglot, Dropshipman, Dsers, etc.
30 eCommerce platforms; 30 popular tools, including Klaviyo, Gorgias, Attentive, Loox, Okendo, Omnisend, etc.
Returns and Exchanges Integration
1 eCommerce platform (Shopify & Shopify Plus); Add-ons of ParcelPanel Order Tracking and Webhooks
14 eCommerce platforms; 15 popular tools, including Klaviyo, Gogias, Zendesk, etc.
Customer Support
Remove the "Powered by" Message
Help Center
24/7 Live Chat Support
Customer Success Manager
Dedicated Onboarding Manager
Dedicated Priority Support
Silver support plan
Gold support plan
Since adding ParcelPanel Returns, we've kept 56% of return revenue, with customers opting for exchanges or store credit.
— Angelica
Chief Operating Officer
View details
Trusted by 50,000+ DTC brands
All-In-One Tracking
Real-time sync & tracking to save your time about focusing on other important things.
Shipping notification
Engage customers through proactive & timely notifications.
Branded tracking page
3.7X lookups per order, bring customers back to your store to make more sales.
Smart analytics
Get powerful insights into your shipping & upsell performance.
Boost additional sales
Engage customers to repurchase through personalized or AI-powered product recommendations.
Seamless integrations
Take the guess work out of integrations and pass the savings on to you.
See other comparisons
.png)
ParcelPanel vs Loop Returns
How does ParcelPanel compare with Loop Returns? What’s the best platform to deliver a good post-purchase experience to shoppers? What is the best alternative to Loop Returns? Discover why ParcelPanel is a great competitor to Loop Returns.
ParcelPanel vs 17TRACK
How does ParcelPanel compare with 17TRACK? What’s the best platform to deliver a good post-purchase experience to shoppers? What is the best alternative to 17TRACK? Discover why ParcelPanel is a great competitor to 17TRACK.
ParcelPanel vs ParcelLab
How does ParcelPanel compare with parcelLab? What’s the best platform to deliver a good post-purchase experience to shoppers? What is the best alternative to parcelLab? Discover why ParcelPanel is a great competitor to parcelLab.
